HOME

INFORMATION
Alternatives
Background Info
Current Status
Links
News
Organizations
Read the R.O.D.
Route Map

PARTICIPATION
Calendar
Commentary
Contacts
Guestbook
Message Board
Get Out the Vote
Contact Us

Summary:
Low Build Approach vs. 710 Freeway

  Low Build Freeway
Cost
  1. $135 million
  2. Elimination of housing rental and maintenance costs since Caltrans owned properties could be returned to private ownership
  1. $1.4 billion for construction
  2. Costs for maintaining and rehabilitating historic homes
  3. Costs for maintaining and renting homes
Time Begin today; complete in 5 years 2020, date shown as needed in SCAG 1998 Regional Transportation Plan
Existing Funding $56.3 million federal appropriation now in place
  1. No State funding
  2. Federal funding is blocked by Congress
  3. ROD requires State to assure funding
Social Costs
  1. Some road and intersection widening
  2. Minimal impacts to sidewalks and buildings
  1. Remove approx. 1,000 homes, many providing affordable housing
  2. Displace 4,000 residents
  3. Remove 6,000 mature trees
  4. Divide neighborhoods
  5. Permanent noise impacts
  6. Air quality impacts
  7. Ongoing landlord-tenant conflicts
Engineering Feasibility Feasible
  1. Questionable whether houses can be replaced on top of cut and cover tunnels
  2. Deep hillside cuts (120 to 160 feet deep)
  3. Excessive dirt removal
  4. Potential sinkage from ground water
  5. Seismic issues
  6. Excessive construction period
  7. ROD requires further engineering feasibility studies
Environmental Issues
  1. Most projects qualify for categorical exemption and negative declarations.
  2. EIR/EIS, if done, would be focused or project specific
  3. Not opposed by Federal agencies
  1. Existing EIR/EIS needs to be redone
  2. ROD requires supplemental EIR/EIS
  3. Historic (Section 4(f)) impacts must be resolved
  4. Clean Air Act impacts must be resolved
  5. EPA, ACHP opposition must be addressed
Results
  1. 100,000 local traffic trips served
  2. Improved surface street operation
  3. Immediate congestion relief
  1. 100,000 local traffic trips served
  2. 100,000 induced regional trips to freeway
  3. Freeway would be congested at opening
  4. Detracts from Blue Line use


The 710 Freeway Fighters
South Pasadena, California