|
|
Low Build |
Freeway |
|
Cost |
- $135 million
- Elimination of housing rental and maintenance costs since Caltrans
owned properties could be returned to private ownership
|
- $1.4 billion for construction
- Costs for maintaining and rehabilitating historic homes
- Costs for maintaining and renting homes
|
|
Time |
Begin today; complete in 5 years |
2020, date shown as needed in SCAG 1998 Regional Transportation Plan
|
|
Existing Funding |
$56.3 million federal appropriation now in place |
- No State funding
- Federal funding is blocked by Congress
- ROD requires State to assure funding
|
|
Social Costs |
- Some road and intersection widening
- Minimal impacts to sidewalks and buildings
|
- Remove approx. 1,000 homes, many providing affordable housing
- Displace 4,000 residents
- Remove 6,000 mature trees
- Divide neighborhoods
- Permanent noise impacts
- Air quality impacts
- Ongoing landlord-tenant conflicts
|
|
Engineering Feasibility |
Feasible |
- Questionable whether houses can be replaced on top of cut and cover tunnels
- Deep hillside cuts (120 to 160 feet deep)
- Excessive dirt removal
- Potential sinkage from ground water
- Seismic issues
- Excessive construction period
- ROD requires further engineering feasibility studies
|
|
Environmental Issues |
- Most projects qualify for categorical exemption and negative declarations.
- EIR/EIS, if done, would be focused or project specific
- Not opposed by Federal agencies
|
- Existing EIR/EIS needs to be redone
- ROD requires supplemental EIR/EIS
- Historic (Section 4(f)) impacts must be resolved
- Clean Air Act impacts must be resolved
- EPA, ACHP opposition must be addressed
|
|
Results |
- 100,000 local traffic trips served
- Improved surface street operation
- Immediate congestion relief
|
- 100,000 local traffic trips served
- 100,000 induced regional trips to freeway
- Freeway would be congested at opening
- Detracts from Blue Line use
|